A Review of the Banished Radical Text They Must Go

 Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, this blog earns a small commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post at no extra cost to you.

When radical right-wing Rabbi Meir Kahane published They Must Go in 1981, he authored one of the most polarizing, inflammatory, and enduring manifestos in the history of modern Middle Eastern politics. Subtitled "How Long Can Israel Survive Its Malignant and Growing Arab Population," the text serves as the absolute foundation for Kahanism—an ultranationalist ideology characterized by racial fundamentalism, violent revenge, and calls for total ethnic segregation.

---

🔒 The Origin: Written from a Prison Cell

The creation of They Must Go is deeply tied to Kahane’s lifelong pattern of political militancy. After founding the militant Jewish Defense League (JDL) in New York in 1968, Kahane immigrated to Israel in 1971, establishing the extremist political party Kach.

[1968: JDL Founded in NY] ──> [1971: Kahane Moves to Israel] ──> [1980: Imprisoned in Ramle] ──> [1981: Manifesto Published]

By 1980, Kahane had been arrested dozens of times. That year, he was placed under a six-month administrative detention order at Ramle Prison following allegations that he was plotting armed attacks against Palestinians. Stripped of a trial, Kahane spent his months behind bars handwriting the manuscript for They Must Go, positioning himself as a political martyr whose ideas were being suppressed by the mainstream establishment. The finished book was published in New York by Grosset & Dunlap in 1981.

---

📜 Summary: The Ultimatum of Separation

At its core, They Must Go presents a grim, zero-sum demographical warning. Kahane argues that western democratic principles and a Jewish state are fundamentally incompatible. He posits that because of higher birth rates, Arab citizens would eventually outvote Jews democratically, ending the Zionist dream without firing a single bullet.

To counter what he termed a "time bomb," Kahane outlined a radical ten-point policy prioritizing uncompromising separation. He offered three ultimatums for non-Jews living in Israel and the occupied territories:

1. Non-Citizenship: Relinquish all political rights and accept a subservient status.
2. Voluntary Emigration: Leave the country willingly in exchange for financial compensation.
3. Forcible Expulsion: Be physically, violently deported by the state without compensation if they refuse to leave.

---

📉 Sales and Reception: Banned and Applauded

Public Repulsion and State Bans

Upon release, the book was widely condemned as unabashedly fascist and racist. Major American Jewish organizations and Israeli political leaders roundly denounced the text. When Kahane won a single seat in the Israeli Knesset in 1984, other parliamentarians routinely walked out of the room en masse whenever he stood up to speak. By 1988, the Israeli government officially banned Kach from running in elections, ruling its platform to be anti-democratic and incitement to racism.

Sales Success

Despite being blacklisted by mainstream bookstores and review outlets, the book found major commercial success within insular, radical right-wing circles in both the United States and Israel. Exact sales figures are difficult to verify due to shifting underground publishers, but the book became a staple text for extremist yeshivas and radical West Bank settler movements, selling tens of thousands of copies over various underground printings.

---

🪦 Legacy and the Cult Following: "Kahane Lives"

Meir Kahane was assassinated in New York City in 1990 by an Egyptian-American militant. Yet, his physical death only accelerated his transformation into a martyr figure for a fierce cult following.

[1990: Kahane Assassinated] ──> [1994: Hebron Massacre / Kach Banned] ──> [Present Day: Kahanism Enters the Establishment]

The Splinter Groups and Disciple Chants

Following his death, his most ardent followers formed the faction Kahane Chai (Kahane Lives). At rallies, protests, and football matches, his fiercely loyal disciples frequently chant the phrase "Kahane Tzadak!" ("Kahane was right!"), alongside violent slogans like "Death to Arabs". This ritualized chanting effectively functions as a pledge of allegiance to the ideas penned in They Must Go.

Terrorist Offshoots

The devastating real-world impact of the book’s ideology materialized in 1994, when American-born physician and devoted Kahane disciple Baruch Goldstein opened fire on Muslim worshippers at the Cave of the Patriarchs in Hebron, killing 29 people. This act of terror prompted Israel, the United States, and the European Union to officially designate Kach and Kahane Chai as active terrorist organizations.

Modern Political Legitimacy

The ultimate irony of Kahane's legacy is its journey from the fringe to the mainstream. Decades after his book was banned, self-identified disciples of Kahane—operating under the political banner of the Otzma Yehudit (Jewish Power) party—have won seats in the Knesset and assumed powerful cabinet positions within the Israeli establishment, such as the ministry overseeing national security.

What was once viewed in 1981 as a dangerous, fringe prison manifesto has slowly transitioned into a visible, highly influential framework for modern right-wing governance in the region. Decades later, They Must Go remains a highly significant text, proving that extremist ideas often outlive the men who write them.

 Purchase a copy of They Must Go on Amazon. (Paid Link)

---